I'm not sure if either of you remember, but two years ago, Mariano Rivera got off to a slow start. He blew a couple of saves and everyone was saying "he's done". It looked like the kryptonite had finally gotten to the Sandman and that would be it. Well, he rebounded and is still the best closer in baseball.
While Jeter isn't the best shortstop in baseball (maybe not top 5 anymore), he's still well above average. If he even has another average here, raising his average to .280 and driving in 50-60 runs while scoring close to 100 at the leadoff spot, that's still better than most shortstops. Still, Jeter has NEVER been a guy you can judge based on numbers. Back in his prime, Nomar, A-Rod and Tejada had better numbers, but Jeter had that "it" factor that made him a star in NY. The key hits, the big plays. THAT is what Jeter is about. If he completely falters and the Yankees completely falter in September and October, we can talk about "done" then. This is April though, so look at his numbers all you want, but with Jeter, it's never been about the numbers.
Hahaa you are so right. So what if Jeter never hits .334 again? The clutchness and leading by example that MADE him the Captian will always be there, and that is what makes him the best at what he does. He's not done until he decides he is.
Saying he will hit 280 might be a stretch since he only hit 270 last season. How much is leadership worth? He isn't done when he says he is done. The decline is happening and maybe that 2009 season was a fluke instead of last season
While the numbers do indicate he is done (or at least on the way), I won't call him done for one reason. As a Red Sox fan, I'm sill terrified of him coming up to bat in a big spot. Until he starts chocking in those moments, he can still play.
I don't know how you can say it isn't about the numbers. This is baseball where all that matters is the numbers. If the Yankees aren't winning championships which they didn't last season then you have to look at Jeter's numbers and think maybe that is why they didn't win.
Also where does Jeter rank on the fear factor for the Yankees? Aren't there at least 2 or 3 guys you'd rather avoid ahead of Jeter?
It's never been about numbers with Jeter. Like I said, in the 90's, he wasn't the best shortstop based on numbers. He never was. It's always been about more with him.
If it's always about numbers, how come in 1998 when all of baseball was jacking home runs and breaking records, the Yankees didn't have a player with more than 30 home runs. That team as you know won 114 games in the regular season and 125 total with the World Series crown. If it was about numbers, surely that team wouldn't have gotten anywhere.
Baseball is a game that is about way more than just your numbers. I'll even give you the benefit of the doubt in saying that Jeter hits .270 again (more of a stretch considering his career average is .314. That's still plenty above average in the league. However, Derek Jeter hitting .270 probably still means that if Derek Jeter is up in the 9th, it DOES scare teams. Ryan was honest about that. Hell, Manny Ramirez just got kicked out of baseball and he was hitting like .190 at the time, but I'd still be fearful of him coming up in a key spot. Some guys just have that "it" factor and Jeter is one of them. On top of that, he dictates the personality of the Yankee clubhouse as its captain. Not too many have had that prestigious honor and he's earn the right to wear the C (metaphorically). If the Yankees compete well this year and Jeter is a part of that in making plays and getting key hits, his manager, his team, and his fans will not look to see if his batting average is below his career numbers.
It's about winning in New York and if Jeter's Yankees (yes they are HIS Yankees more than any other player) are winning, nobody is going to worry too much about Jeter's numbers.
Jeter isn't a first ballot Hall of Famer, hate to break it to you what he'll be remember for is that he constantly needed help in the lineup and could never do it on his own.
You must be logged in leave a comment.
A FanVsFan Challenge is a structured debate between two fans. Each fan gets two turns to prove their case and silence their rival. Other fans can view, vote and comment on the debate. Get involved and vote on the debates below.
See Full Leaderboard
Masahiro Tanaka Hits Roadblock in Comeback Attempt
Last Night on the Farm - 8/28/14
Mike Minor Makes Major Effort in Braves Win over Mets
Angels and A's Prepare For Crucial Four Game Set
Gehrig Day Yankees Jerseys Auction To Benefit ALS Research
Last Night on the Farm - 8/27/14